The best cashback deal is the purchase you didn’t make. The second best is the one you were going to make anyway – and now get a few percent back on.
The short answer
Cashback is only worth it as a discount on things you’d buy regardless. If the percentages make you order more, you haven’t saved anything; you’ve spent. Three more things eat into the discount: returns that cancel the cashback, purchases that never get tracked, and the data you hand over. Six habits get you the most out of it while keeping the risks above in view. We’ve covered how individual sites differ in our site comparison; this guide is about practice.
The six rules
- Decide first, then click. Build your basket in peace, without the cashback site. Answer “Do I need this?” before the cashback enters the picture, not after. The German consumer advice centre (Verbraucherzentrale) warns that supermarket apps can tempt you into impulse and extra purchases through more exposure to ads (source below); cashback banners work the same way. Our own tip, not from a study: for anything above your usual budget, sleep on it. Some promotions are time-limited and may end before you decide, in which case you miss the bonus. In return, a purchase you no longer want after a night’s sleep costs you nothing.
- Compare the price without cashback. Cashback is a rebate on the price, not the price itself. An example with assumed numbers, not market data: an item costs €100 at shop A. At shop B it costs €103 with an assumed 3% cashback. Three percent of €103 leaves €99.91 – a gain of nine cents on paper. If the site calculates the percentage on the goods value without tax and shipping, shop A is cheaper. According to our provider profiles, Shoop and iGraal pay no cashback on shipping and VAT. So compare final prices in a price comparison first and use cashback only as the tie-breaker when prices are equal.
- Plan for returns. Cashback is a commission passed on to you. The shop waits to see whether you send something back. The Rakuten help centre, for example, says cashback is rejected if you return or cancel the purchase. That’s no reason to give up your right of withdrawal: according to the consumer advice centre, you usually have 14 days from delivery for online orders. But for items you’ll probably return (shoes in two sizes, say), don’t count the cashback at all. A “pending” amount isn’t earned money.
- Keep tracking clean. According to Stiftung Warentest, cashback only works with cookies enabled: that’s how the shop knows you came from the site. That’s why purchases often don’t count when an ad blocker is running, when you switch browsers midway or when you enter a voucher code from another site. The exact exclusions differ by site and sit in their terms; for iGraal’s rule on third-party voucher codes, see the provider profile. Keep it simple: enter through the site, fill the basket in the same browser window, pay, done.
- Save proof, note the deadline. Keep the order confirmation and date. Check after a few days that the purchase shows up on the site, and put the site’s claim deadline in your calendar. Deadlines differ; the details are at TopCashback, iGraal and Shoop. What to do when a payout goes missing is covered in our guide Account locked or payout missing.
- Share as little data as you can. As early as 2015, Stiftung Warentest argued a provider needs at most your name, email address and bank details. The consumer advice centre describes how companies build profiles from loyalty-card purchase data and advises giving only what’s necessary. According to the PCWorld author, sites with a browser extension collect considerably more than plain cashback offers: pages visited, abandoned carts, timestamps. Her suggestion: keep an extension active only when you plan to buy, or use a separate browser for cashback purchases. That’s your decision.
Which approach fits you?
- You rarely shop online: you’ll reach the payout threshold late. Check the thresholds in the Shoop, iGraal and TopCashback profiles. If it takes more than a year, signing up hardly pays off.
- You’re planning a big purchase: this is where cashback works best, because a small percentage lands on a large amount. Allow for the confirmation time and return window, because a large amount also means a large potential loss.
- You shop at the supermarket: receipt and brochure cashback follows other rules because there’s no click tracking. marktguru, for instance, pays a small amount per receipt according to the provider; the profile explains what’s behind it. The consumer advice centre points out for loyalty cards and supermarket apps that you pay with your data; check that here too.
Frequently asked questions
- How much does it bring per year? That depends entirely on what you buy online. We don’t have a reliable average figure. Work from your last twelve months of orders and the percentages of the shops you buy from.
- Can I send goods back? Yes. Your right of withdrawal stays intact. The cashback is then usually reduced or cancelled.
- Should I install a browser extension? Not if you don’t need one. Going through the site’s page is enough. Stiftung Warentest advises enabling plug-ins only for the shopping trip and disabling them afterwards.
- Do I have to pay tax on cashback? We don’t give an answer here. Tax treatment isn’t part of our review; ask the tax office or a tax adviser.
Checklist before you click
- Check whether you’d buy the item without cashback.
- Compare the final price including shipping at two shops at least.
- Turn off your ad blocker and leave no voucher code from another site in the basket.
- Enter through the site and buy in the same window.
- Save the order confirmation and date.
- Note the date to check the booking and the claim deadline.
- Don’t treat “pending” cashback as a balance.
A note on partner links
If a partner link is active for one of the providers mentioned, it appears below the article and is labelled “Partner link”; the rating and the order do not depend on it. The money-note rating never depends on commissions; more is on our Transparency page and in our methodology. All cashback providers with ratings and sources are in the comparison.
Sources (all retrieved 23 Oct 2026)
- Verbraucherzentrale: supermarket apps – discounts and risks (updated 26 Aug 2026, German)
- Verbraucherzentrale: loyalty cards – small discounts for lots of data (German)
- Verbraucherzentrale: withdrawal rights online (updated 5 Aug 2026, German)
- Stiftung Warentest: discount apps – how loyalty cards and cashback work (December 2015, older test, German)
- Rakuten.de help centre: pending and available cashback (German)
- PCWorld: The hidden cost of cashback (30 Jan 2026)
Provider details carry their own source and date in the profiles. Sites change their rules; check them before you buy. Bytearium does not give tax or legal advice.